Our Menu
We make our steak Philly the way we ought to -with fresh steak sliced thin in our kitchen daily, locally baked bread, and housemade cheese wiz. No fillers, no canned sauce, and produce cut daily - the Philgeddaboutit way!
Appetizers
Our appetizers, sauces, and dips are made in-house from fresh ingredients. When possible, we support local farmers and dairy
Mafia Mozz
$8.00
Skewers of battered and fried mozzarella dusted with parmesan. Served with warm marinara
Fried Pepperoni
$8.50
Dusted with parmesan and Italian shake. Served with ranch and pickled peperoncini
Merlino's Fried Pickles
$7.00
Dill slices are lightly dusted and fried. Served with our housemade ranch
Bar Snacks
Fresh Fried Potato Crisps W Dip
$6.00
Basket with Housemade French Onion
Basket O' Fries
$6.00
Loaded with cheese/bacon +$4
Authentic Steaks
Not feeling steak? Sub-sliced chicken $1. Skipping the meats? Sub fresh sliced garlic mushrooms $2
The Original
$10.00
Fresh sliced steak, grilled onions, housemade cheddar wiz
The New Guy
$11.00
Steak, grilled onions and peppers, choice of wiz, lettuce, tomato, and BabyFace sauce
The Hot Shot
$11.00
Steak, tabasco onions, green peppers, spicy wiz, house giardiniera
The Black Eye
$12.00
Blackened steak, Buffalo Trace caramelized onions, garlic mushrooms, blue cheese cream sauce
The Edgardo
$12.00
Cheesesteak meets Pizza! Steak, smoked provolone, housemade marinara, oregano, and pepperoni
The Capone
$14.00
The Boss of our Phillies: Steak, peppered ham, genoa salami, pepperoni, onions, bell peppers, smoked provolone, house giardiniera, BabyFace Sauce
Chicken Phils
Parma Sean Chicken
$10.00
Breaded chunks of chicken, smoked provolone, house marinara, and parmesan cheese on a garlic hoagie roll
The Buffalo Bugsy
$11.00
Sliced chicken, grilled onions and peppers, our housemade buffalo sauce, and blue cheese cream sauce
The Teriyaki Yakuza
$12.00
Chicken, provolone, grilled onions and peppers, pineapple, housemade teriyaki-pineapple sauce, sriracha drizzle
Chicken Bacon Ranch
$11.00
Chicken, bacon, provolone, ranch, and diced tomato. John Dutton would be proud!
Add a side to any Phil:
Fresh Chips $1, Housemade Totz $2, Seasoned Fries $3, Loaded Peppers/Onions Cheese +$1 .5, Loaded Cheese/Bacon +$3, Cowboy Caviar $3.5, Assorted Deli Salad $3
Hoagies and Melts
The Goodfella
$10.00
Peppered ham, genoa salami, pepperoni, and provolone. Topped with lettuce, tomato, our pickled sweet peppers, and our housemade Italian juice
The Meatball Hoagie
$11.00
Housemade Beef and Pork meatballs roasted in our own marinara. Served on a provolone-lined roll and dusted with parmesan | Add fried pepperoni +$1
Dillinger's Chicago Beef Dip
$12.00
USDA Prime beef rubbed with 14 spices and roasted over 6 hours. Lined with provolone and topped with spicy giardiniera. Order this and Fugeddaboutit!
Pizza Sub
$10.00
Open-faced with housemade marinara, provolone, and crispy pepperoni | Add Onions and Green Peppers +$1
The Philly Melt
$10.00
Steak, double provolone, Buffalo Trace caramelized onions, and Babyface sauce on locally made sourdough
Made Man Melt
$11.00
Steak, double bacon, double provolone, tabasco onions, and steakhouse aioli on locally made sourdough
Falters Fried Bologna Sandwich
$7.00
Thick cut with grilled onions and American
ADD A SIDE:
Chips $1, Housemade Totz $3, Deli Salad $3, Cowboy Caviar $3.5
Wings
Wings Smoked or Double Fried Traditional
We use fresh, never-frozen jumbo wings. Our smoked wings are roasted in a blend of cherry, maple, and hickory woods and then fried for added crispiness. Our traditional wings are coated and double fried for the perfect crunch. Each and every sauce is made in-house
6 Piece Wings
$8.50
12 Piece Wings - Flavor
$16.00
Boneless Chunks
$7.50
For those who want to keep their hands clean. 1/2 pound, hand breaded
Ranch or Blue Cheese
$0.80
Celery and Carrots +$1
Sweet Sauces
Honey Bourbon Molasses (with Buffalo Trace bourbon), Pineapple Teriyaki, Tangy Carolina Gold
Sweet with A Lil' Heat
Spicy Georgia Peach, Caribbean Sting, Wiseguy (Honey-Sriracha-Garlicy), Jalapeno Raspberry
The Heat (In Order of Spiciness)
Mild Buffalo, Hot Buffalo, Chipotle BBQ, Five Pepper, Ghost of Gambino, Reaper's Revenge (Enforcer level stuff 'ight here, boss- +$1)
Savory
Garlic, Garlic & Ginger, Miyagi (the OG Gangster!), Garlic Parmesan
Dry Rub
Ragin Cajun, Chipotle Blackberry, Bang Bang
Greens
Make any sandwich a salad for +$3
Whittier St Salad
$13.00
Sauteed steak, grilled onions, peppers, shredded cheddar, tomato
Mr Barker's Salad
$13.00
Sauteed chicken, bacon, tomatoes, cheddar, sweet peppers
House Dressings:
Italian Juice, Ranch, Blue Cheese, Babyface
Burgers
Our burgers are a 5oz blend of brisket/chuck on a locally-made rosemary brioche bun. Sub a Beyond patty for +$3
Philgeddaboutit Burger
$10.00
Grilled peppers, onions, provolone, and house Wiz
The Black Hand Burger
$12.00
Blackened with provolone, sauteed mushrooms, tobacco onions, and blue cheese cream sauce
BYOB BURGER
Cheese $0.80, Mushrooms $1.50, Veggies $0.80, Wiz $1, Bacon $3